MadeInThePastPaperCo
Open 3 years
Sales
2.9K
Reviews
818
Rating
5.0
Listings
84
Price Range
$5.75–$6.75
median $5.95
Keywords
2
tracked
Category Focus
Scrapbooking Ephemera 57% Seasonal Decor 43%
Your Keywords
Where this shop shows up in Etsy search
Your keyword opportunities
Sorted by competition — lower = bigger opportunity for you
Related niches to explore
Product categories related to what you make
Art & Collectibles
Vintage Soviet Film Cameras and Accessories
94/100 $24.99
Weddings
Chiavari Chair Cushions and Covers
92/100 $9.89
Plants & Gardening
Lisianthus Plant Plugs and Seeds
91/100 $22.95
Craft Supplies & Tools
Icelandic Lopi Sweater Knitting Patterns
90/100 $13.00
Art & Collectibles
The Rookie TV Show Fan Merchandise
90/100 $23.12
Jewelry
Vintage Piaget Luxury Watches and Jewelry
89/100 $3,250
Clothing
Classic Rock Band Merchandise T-Shirts
89/100 $58.60
Craft Supplies & Tools
LaBlanche Silicone Molds for Crafting
89/100 $29.59
Your Listings
Sorted by favorites — with keyword positions
1
Vintage Halloween Ephemera Paper Cut Out, Vintage Halloween Decorations, Halloween Decor, Halloween Die Cut, Retro Hallo
$5.95 · 299 favorites
2
Vintage Halloween Advertisements Vintage Halloween Decor Halloween Decorations Junk Journal Ephemera Scrapbooking Hallow
$6.75 · 139 favorites
3
Vintage Halloween Costume, Vintage Halloween Decoration, Halloween Decor, Retro Halloween, Vintage Beistle, Halloween Ju
$5.99 · 130 favorites
4
Vintage Halloween Pumpkin Seals, Printed Vintage Halloween Paper Decorations High-Quality Laser Reproductions Scrapbooki
$5.95 · 99 favorites
5
Vintage 12PC Halloween Blow Mold Pumpkin, Jack-o-Lantern Cutouts, Halloween Paper Decorations High-Quality Laser Reprodu
$5.75 · 67 favorites
6
Halloween Ephemera, Halloween Junk Journal, Vintage Halloween Decoration, Halloween Decor, Halloween Die Cut, Retro Hall
$5.75 · 34 favorites
7
Vintage 1960s Brach’s Easter Candy Advertisements 12 Piece, Easter Die Cut, High-quality Laser Reproduction, Easter Stic
$5.99 · 27 favorites
Full competitive report — MadeInThePastPaperCo's market
What the shops you'd compete against actually sell — measured from six months of their real Etsy transaction counts, not estimated from reviews or listing age. Drawn from 1.5M+ Etsy shops tracked since March 2026.
- Orders/week for the typical competitor, and for the top 10%
- How many competitors sell nothing at all
- Price position and where the gaps are
- Six-month trajectory — growing, flat, or cooling