OldtimePicker
Open 8 years
Sales
4.1K
Reviews
807
Rating
4.7
Listings
66
Price Range
$4.50–$5.00
median $4.50
Keywords
5
tracked
Category Focus
Sports Collectibles 100%
Your Keywords
Where this shop shows up in Etsy search
Your keyword opportunities
Sorted by competition — lower = bigger opportunity for you
Related niches to explore
Product categories related to what you make
Art & Collectibles
Jujutsu Kaisen Anime Fan Merchandise
79/100 $21.41
Toys & Games
Sidon Plush Toys and Merchandise
78/100 $94.69
Art & Collectibles
My Chemical Romance Killjoys Merchandise
74/100 $9.00
Art & Collectibles
Alex Ovechkin Hockey Fan Merchandise
73/100 $79.90
Clothing
Kansas City Sports Digital Designs & Apparel
68/100 $4.00
Art & Collectibles
Vintage POGs and Slammers Collection Lots
67/100 $20.00
Art & Collectibles
Cult of the Lamb & Inscryption Fan Merchandise
65/100 $8.87
Toys & Games
Arcane League of Legends Fan Merchandise
54/100 $19.50
Your Listings
Sorted by favorites — with keyword positions
1
1982 TCMA Baseball #13 John Elway [] Oneonta Yankees (RC) RP
$4.50 · 42 favorites
2
1951 Baseball #253 Mickey Mantle [] New York Yankees (RC) RP
$4.50 · 26 favorites
3
1985/86 O-Pee-Chee Hockey #9 Mario Lemieux {} Pittsburgh Penguins (RC) Border Error (RP)
$4.50 · 25 favorites
4
1968 Plaks Baseball CL #2 Hank Aaron/Willie Mays/Pete Rose/Roberto Clemente/Allen/Davis/Drysdale/Cepeda/Santo/Staub/McCa
$5.00 · 18 favorites
Full competitive report — OldtimePicker's market
What the shops you'd compete against actually sell — measured from six months of their real Etsy transaction counts, not estimated from reviews or listing age. Drawn from 1.5M+ Etsy shops tracked since March 2026.
- Orders/week for the typical competitor, and for the top 10%
- How many competitors sell nothing at all
- Price position and where the gaps are
- Six-month trajectory — growing, flat, or cooling