NostalgicPander
Open 5 years
Sales
14.8K
Reviews
2.7K
Rating
4.9
Listings
762
Price Range
$6.99–$22.99
median $9.99
Keywords
9
tracked
Category Focus
Game Pieces 29% Comics & Graphic Novels 29% Stuffed Animals & Plushies 14% Children's Books 14% Sports Collectibles 14%
Your Keywords
Where this shop shows up in Etsy search
Your keyword opportunities
Sorted by competition — lower = bigger opportunity for you
pogs case
You rank #1 of 20 listings
nfl mini mug
You rank #1 of 48 listings
slammer pog
You rank #19 of 360 listings
pogs and slammers
You rank #3 of 367 listings
punisher comic books
You rank #2 of 422 listings
beany baby
You rank #11 of 535 listings
pogs for kids
You rank #4 of 604 listings
valiant
You rank #3 of 2.3K listings
sleuth
You rank #15 of 2.4K listings
Your Competitors
Shops that fight you for the same buyers
| Shop | Sales | Head-to-head | Shared kws |
|---|---|---|---|
| WonderlandToys pogs and slammers, pogs for kids, slammer pog | 29.8K | 2W–1L | 3 |
| RigbysRetro pogs and slammers, pogs for kids, slammer pog | 486 | 3W–0L | 3 |
| Solarislenses pogs and slammers, pogs for kids, slammer pog | 2.0K | 3W–0L | 3 |
| MistyFallsShop pogs and slammers, pogs for kids, slammer pog | 3.4K | 0W–3L | 3 |
| NoahsRose pogs and slammers, pogs for kids, slammer pog | 2.1K | 1W–2L | 3 |
| AnalogPOG pogs and slammers, pogs for kids, slammer pog | 97 | 2W–1L | 3 |
| spoiledrottentoys pogs case, pogs for kids | 1.5K | 2W–0L | 2 |
| IansRecordClocks pogs and slammers, slammer pog | 77.4K | 1W–1L | 2 |
| PicksByBear pogs and slammers, slammer pog | 968 | 2W–0L | 2 |
| WolfgangVintageWares pogs and slammers, pogs for kids | 6.5K | 2W–0L | 2 |
| POGshopUK pogs and slammers, pogs for kids | 448 | 2W–0L | 2 |
| LegendsOfTheirTime pogs and slammers, slammer pog | 698 | 2W–0L | 2 |
| BluebirdVariety pogs and slammers, pogs for kids | 37 | 2W–0L | 2 |
| JeepersSqueakers pogs and slammers, slammer pog | 16.1K | 1W–1L | 2 |
Your Pricing Position
How your prices compare to the niche sweet spot
pogs lot
You
$9.99
vs
Niche
$24.00
-58%
Related niches to explore
Product categories related to what you make
Craft Supplies & Tools
Icelandic Lopi Sweater Knitting Patterns
90/100 $13.00
Toys & Games
Scented Crunchy Slime
87/100 $13.97
Art & Collectibles
Jujutsu Kaisen Anime Fan Merchandise
79/100 $21.41
Toys & Games
Sidon Plush Toys and Merchandise
78/100 $94.69
Paper & Party Supplies
Sprunki Game Fan Party Products
77/100 $12.99
Art & Collectibles
My Chemical Romance Killjoys Merchandise
74/100 $9.00
Paper & Party Supplies
Skibidi Toilet Merchandise and Crafts
73/100 $3.16
Art & Collectibles
Alex Ovechkin Hockey Fan Merchandise
73/100 $79.90
Your Listings
Sorted by favorites — with keyword positions
1
Vintage Pogs With Carrying Case - Slammers Included! -Choose From List - See Description - 90s Nostalgia
$22.99 · 353 favorites
2
Vintage Pogs - 10 pogs + 1 Slammer / Milk Caps Random Selection
$9.99 · 346 favorites
3
TY Beanie Baby Goody Gingerbread Bear - 2004 Holiday Plush
$9.99 · 9 favorites
4
Marvel Knights The Punisher Vol 4 #21 - Brotherhood Part 2 of 3 | DC Comics | Vintage 2003
$6.99 · 2 favorites
5
NFL Minatare Mini Mugs - Lot of 3 - Vintage Vending Machine
$13.99 · 2 favorites
6
Vintage Teen Mystery Paperback: Super Sleuth by Jackie Vivelo, 1980s Scholastic
$8.99 · 1 favorites
7
Death Mate Comics Lot of #1 and Prologue | Valiant Comics | Vintage 1993
$14.99 · 0 favorites
Full competitive report — NostalgicPander's market
What the shops you'd compete against actually sell — measured from six months of their real Etsy transaction counts, not estimated from reviews or listing age. Drawn from 1.5M+ Etsy shops tracked since March 2026.
- Orders/week for the typical competitor, and for the top 10%
- How many competitors sell nothing at all
- Price position and where the gaps are
- Six-month trajectory — growing, flat, or cooling